WirelessWeek.com

Log in | Register
<!-- Insert your title here -->

Daily news and top headlines for wireless professionals

FREE Email Newsletter View Sample »

  

Analysis: Wireless Tax Relief Bill Has Grim History


Loading...

Admittedly, no one likes taxes, but things have gotten a bit out of control in the wireless space.

The typical wireless consumer pays 15.2 percent of their total bill in federal, state and local taxes, fees and surcharges. That’s more than double the average tax rate for other goods and services, which is about 7 percent.

According to CTIA, taxes on wireless services increased four times faster than the rate on other taxable goods and services between January 2003 and July Wireless Tax Relief Bill2007. Twenty-one states now impose double-digit state and local transaction taxes on wireless services. 

To that end, the Mobile Wireless Tax Fairness Act was introduced in the U.S. senate this week by U.S. Senators Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) and Olympia Snowe (R-Maine). The bill calls for a five-year halt on new wireless-specific taxes by state and local authorities, and should help municipalities gradually wean themselves off of inflated wireless tax revenues.

CTIA and a host of companies, including Verizon Wireless, applauded the initiative. Most of the taxes have a historic basis that goes back for decades. For example, they once paid for telecommunications companies’ use of public land for large-scale infrastructure deployment.

Although the rationale for such taxes has long since passed, municipalities have become dependent on the revenue they generate, and similar bills have failed in the past.

In 2006, a cell phone tax moratorium proposed by Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.), died before reaching a full floor vote. In 2007, the Cell Phone Tax Moratorium Act met the same fate, followed by the Cell Tax Fairness Act in 2008, which also failed to reach a full floor vote.

“[Cities] sort of forgot about all the rationales and just said the taxes were functionally equivalent, so you have a two- or three-decades-old tax policy being applied to a 21st century marketplace,” says Scott Mackey, an economist at Kimbell Sherman Ellis who previously conducted research about wireless taxes and fees for CTIA.

The state of the economy will make stemming any revenue stream a difficult pitch to make, especially given the bill’s track record.

Mackey’s final words: Given the huge reliance on these revenues, the best the industry can do is get a moratorium and give states time to reform.

More FirstNews 06/11/09:
•  Rubinstein Replaces Colligan as Palm CEO
•  iSuppli: Pre Costlier than Expected
•  Analysis: Wireless Tax Relief Bill Has Grim History
•  Qualcomm Raises 3Q Guidance
•  Survey: More Phones = More Storage
•  Whitacre Sees Role at GM as Public Service
•  USA Today Publisher Sees Hope in Mobile Platforms
•  FirstNews Briefs for June 11, 2009

 

Loading...
Latest Cell Phone Accessories,
Batteries, Covers, and Cases
with Free shipping!


The #1 Source for cell phone accessories
And the largest iPhone Case selection online

Huge selection of Cell Phone Cases
Including disount iPhone Covers

Ten-Yard Penalty, Failure to Engage Via Mobile

Ten-Yard Penalty, Failure to Engage Via Mobile

I was about as impressed with attempts to integrate mobile with this year's Super Bowl as I was with the Green Bay Packers’ effort during their NFC divisional playoff loss to the New York Giants.


LightSquared Deserves a Hearing

LightSquared Deserves a Hearing

The government should figure out how the LightSquared saga came to be.


In Other News: Patents

In Other News: Patents

The tech industry may have had its attention focused on gadgets this week due to the annual hullaballoo at the 2012 International CES show in Las Vegas, but at least a few people were thinking about the patented inventions that make those electronics work.


Loading...
<!-- Insert your title here -->

Free Wireless Industry
Subscriptions

Magazine

wireless week

Newsletters

newsletters

Sign up now ►

Top Stories and Headlines
EVERY DAY!

Free Email Newsletter